Role of Persuasion: Investigating the Impact of Social
Media on Buying Decision Process of Digital Natives
Ramandeep Saini,
Professor
Department of Management,
Faculty
of Management,
Chandigarh Group of
Colleges,
Landran, Mohali,
India
Lovedeep Singh Sidhu
Research
Scholar,
Department
of Management,
I.K. Gujral Punjab
Technical University, Kapurthala, India
&
Assistant
Professor
Department of Management
Chandigarh
Group of Colleges,
Landran,
Mohali, India.
Abstract
Social media is that
one digital platform which has evolved into major
player for digital marketing. The study examines the influence of social media on
buying decision process of digital natives and checked whether this influence
varies at the all stages of this process. A quantitative research method is
adopted by choosing stratified proportionate sampling technique for collecting
data of 350 digital natives that use social media in Chandigarh, India. For
this purpose, a structured questionnaire is framed. The results have clearly
indicated the existence of association between buying decision process of
digital natives and social media, where social media affects the consumer
purchase behavior positively. Information Stage of this process is mostly
affected by social media, pursued by purchase decision. Furthermore, we found
that E-word of mouth and social media content are the prominent factors of
social media which impact buying decision process.
Keywords:
Social media, digital
marketing, Consumer buying decision process,
E-word of mouth, digital natives.
By 2021, the count of users on social
media is likely to reach one third of the total world population. This
escalating count of user accounts is because of rapid growth in user immersion,
as per day 135 minutes on social networks is the average time spent by internet
users. (M. Gómez, et al., 2019). The immense usage of social media has
led to formation of Social Media Big Data (S. Stieglitz et al., 2018). Use of
social media is not only changing people’s lifestyles, their learning behavior
and way of communication with one another; rather elementary shifts are also occurring
within businesses. Social media is a digital tool used by brands and retailers
to elevate customer’s involvement, thus make a way to alter their customer’s
buying intentions. Social media offers a display place for business houses to have
interaction with prospects where it encourages intimacy with consumers, thus
build associations with them. (McClure, C., & Seock, K. 2020). Social media
let consumers create information and share experiences with their pals,
businesses, and online communities through shares, posts, likes, tweets, retweets,
rating and reviews. In this era of
digital competition, companies engage consumers first, then continually
introduces the same product, intensify appeal of product to make consumers
rethink. (K.-Y. Kwahk, B. Kim,2017). Distribution of information about
products and services like launch of new product lines, spreading brand
awareness, and strategies to alter consumer behavior has become very convenient
on social media. (Pütter,
M., 2017).
Theoretical
Foundation
Social Media
Social media
is a set of applications mainly based on web that construct on the technological
and ideological fundamentals of Web 2.0. It lets users to generate and trade
content material (Prodanova & Looy, 2019). They are
considered as social channels that use the web and mobile technologies for developing
communication. Web 2.0
helps social media users to develop their own content and raise their voice on
digital world. Social media has a feature of being interactive and participative.
(Kaplan & Haenlein, 2010). Social media has entirely altered the way people
used to interact with each other’s in centuries ago. It has lent services for
online user interaction, user engagement and undeniably altered company–consumer
relationship. Social media has
developed into new field of digital profit-making opportunity for companies to
build their brand image, convey brand story and strengthening overall brand
management. (M. Gómez, et al., 2019). It develops direct
connection between companies and consumers (Kaplan & Haenlein, 2010). Now,
consumers are recipient of content as well as active creators of brand value and
brand information. Power over control of content is shifted from brands owners
to consumers. This surprising switch has
opened gateway for companies to new challenges and opportunities in digital
world. Social media is divided into
several categories including Twitter, Instagram, Snapchat, You Tube, WhatsApp, Wine,
Tik Tok, pin interest, (Kaplan,
A. M., Haenlein, M., 2010, Kizgin, H., et al., 2017, Prodanova, J., Looy, A.V.,
2019). In this modern era, Social media is now an inseparable part of people’s life,
distinctively among adolescents and teenagers. Adolescents and teenagers are referred
as Generation Z (also called as digital natives, i Generation and Generation next)
and have actively follow online integrated communication platform (Duffett,
R. G. 2018).
Generation
cohort
Generation is defined as the year’s term
that the individuals live or a cohort of specific year. There are different
generation cohorts and each generation cohort show a different set of
behavioral characteristics that are contributed and influenced by the era of
their birth. Digital natives are born between years 1995 – 2012, and also known
as Me Generation, plurals, Generation N. (Rahmat, N.H. et al., 2018). Generation
Z is the first generation to which immense information and extensively various
social networking sites are directly available on the internet (Mat Salleh, M.
S., et al., 2017).
Buying Decision Process
Buying decision process is known as consumer
decision making process or consumer buying process (Kotler and Keller 2016, p.
181-182), It is referred as process of consumption, in which consumers go
through multiple stages that construct their thought of buying a product and
service.
The first Stage of this process is problem
recognition. The process
starts with the buyer. Buyers identify a need generated by stimuli may be
internal or external (D. Voramontri and L. Klieb, 2018). In case of internal
stimulus, normal needs of any person– food, thirst, shelter sex get higher to a
threshold level and turn out to be a drive. Few needs can be generated by an
external stimulus. A person may like a new mobile of his friend or explore
Instagram advertisements for a Dubai vacation, which may arise a thought of
making a purchase. After this, consumers reach to Information search stage. The
drive to get new product makes consumers to make searches for the particular
product. Generally, consumers search
for limited information. There are multiple sources of information collection
and all these sources vary consumer to consumer (Kotler and Keller, 2016). Major
information sources are categorized into 4 groups.
Personnel: Family, neighbors, friends,
Acquaintances. Commercials: Websites, Advertising, Emails, Dealers, Sales
Persons, Packing, Public: Social Media, Mass media, consumer rating
organization, Experiential: Managing, investigating, and utilizing product. All
sources perform a different function in changing the buying decision. Many
consumers switch between going offline and online to get information about
different products and all the stage of
the consumer buying decision process is impacted through social media in the
Sri Lanka, but the major impacts are on information stage, evaluation stage and
post- purchase stage. Openness,
Participation, Connectedness, Conversation and Communality are features of
Social Media. Then the consumers go to third stage of evaluation of
alternatives. Final value judgment depends on how the consumers evaluates the
collected information. In all buying situations, consumers go for multiple
stage of evaluation. Then, consumers make judgment mostly on rational and
conscious basis. Consumer evaluation processes follows three main stages.
First, the consumers make effort to satisfy new needs. Next, the consumers expect
some benefits from the product. Then, the consumers try to look at each product
as bundle of attribute with varying abilities. On the basis of this, consumer
makes preferences among their likings. Then finally, stage of purchase decision
comes where consumer is mostly confused what to buy. Purchase decision
completely depends on purchase intention of consumers. Here, two factors play
an important role, attitude of others and unanticipated
situational elements. Purchase decision
is the most crucial step in the whole process as it comes with some risk.
Consumers trust a product and buy it to satisfy their needs. In case, the
product does not live up to their expectation, and then they do not prefer
buying same product. The last stage is Post purchase behavior. Here, consumers express their satisfaction and dissatisfaction
towards purchased product. They express their feelings through numerous modes
like, reviews, ratings, opinions, feedback.
Literature Review
Social media is defined as an evolving
interdisciplinary research field which intends to combine, extend, and adapt
methods for social media’s data analysis (S. Stieglitz et al., 2018).
The study explained that web 2.0, social media, and user generated content, all
are interrelated with each other. The various categories of Social Media are
content communities, blogs, Collaborative projects, virtual social worlds, social
networking sites, virtual game worlds, rating and review sites, video casts and
podcasts, micro-blogging sites and multimedia sharing sites. (Kaplan, A. M., Haenlein, M., 2010). Social
Media is providing opportunity to business houses to increase their customer
database for more opportunities (Prodanova, J., Looy, A.V., 2019). Social media
is most popular activity online among users as it connects millions of
consumers with each other’s by sharing their thoughts, views about different
products and brands. The social media known entirely by social networking sites
are one of the vital fields for the businesses. Social media is a significant
tool in supporting consumer engagement. Twitter, YouTube, and Facebook develop
bond with consumers by creating interactions of consumers with content of their
liked brand. Companies are opening their social media profiles to reach,
engage, and maintain a consumer base. User-generated content is getting all the
attentions of marketers as it allows consumers to post in response to certain
brands, brands requests. Other users check the posted comments and change their
buying intention. (Pütter, M.,2018). Consumer immersion with Social media
marketing has a constructive effect on consumers brand awareness and their
purchase intentions. Social media has significantly affected both businesses
and consumers. A very fewer number of empirical works have
been commenced in India in this evolving area but in future it will pay huge
contribution to the researchers, marketers, stakeholders and academicians (Asma,
G., Misbah, M.,2018). Most of the companies use social media reports for product
placement as well in the social web (S. Stieglitz et al., 2018). All the stage of the consumer buying decision
process is being impacted by social media in the Sri Lanka, but the major
impacts are on information stage, evaluation stage and post- purchase stage.
Openness, Participation, Connectedness,
Conversation and Communality are features of Social Media. The factors of
social media like recommendations, contents, reviews and opinions about
performances of companies, have impact on consumer’s buying decisions.
(Madhuhansi, W. H. 2019). Content on social media is highly impactful on
consumer purchase intention. By like, comment and sharing the content on social
media, people gave a sign that they have read it and are agreed on the content
written about certain products or services. (Karunanayak, Madubashini, 2019). Social
media have power to influence some aspects of consumer behavior like, awareness,
information acquisition, opinions, attitudes, and their decision-making process.
(Asma, G., Misbah, M.,2018). Review of literature provides roadmap to further investigation so, after
reviewing literature, we found that there are six major drivers or factors of
social media that affect buying decision process of consumers and these are;
Social media influencers, entertainment, social media advertising, reviews and
rating , content, and E-word of mouth.
Figure 1. Research Model (developed by author (2020) based on
literature)
Independent variables Dependent variable
Factors
of Social Media Buying decision process
Need
recognition |
Information search |
Evaluation of alternatives |
Purchase Decision |
Post purchase behavior |
The primary research objective is to
study the influence of social media on buying decision process of digital natives. The primary research
objective is fulfilled by following secondary objectives
along with hypotheses.
1.
To
study the impact of factors of social
media on need recognition.
H1: Factors of social media have no substantial impact on need recognition.
2. To determine the impact of factors of social media on information search
H2: Factors of social media have no substantial impact on search of information.
3.
To
evaluate the impact of factors of social
media on evaluation of alternative.
H3: Factors of social media have
no substantial impact on evaluation of alternatives.
4.
To
analyze the impact of factors of social
media on purchase decision.
H4:
Factors of social media have
no substantial impact media on purchase
decision.
5. To study the impact of factors of social media on post purchase behavior.
H5: Factors of social media have no substantial impact on post-purchase
behaviour.
Research Method
Table 1: Analysis of Social Media
usage and demographic variables
Variable |
|
Frequency |
Valid
Percentage |
Gender |
Male |
172 |
49 |
Female |
178 |
51 |
|
Education |
Higher
School |
58 |
17 |
Diploma |
40 |
11 |
|
Bachelor |
93 |
27 |
|
Post
Graduate |
159 |
45 |
|
Age |
Less
than 15 years |
38 |
11 |
15-20 |
61 |
17 |
|
20-25 |
251 |
72 |
|
Residential
Status |
Urban |
189 |
54 |
Rural |
161 |
46 |
|
Do you use social media? |
Yes |
350 |
100 |
No |
0 |
0 |
|
How long have you been using Social Media? |
Less than 6 months |
0 |
0 |
6 months to 1 year |
42 |
12 |
|
1 to 2
years |
148 |
42 |
|
2 years or more |
160 |
46 |
|
On an average, how many hours
daily do you spend on Social Media? |
Less than an hour |
157 |
45 |
1 to 2
hours |
16 |
5 |
|
2 to 5
hours |
138 |
39 |
|
More than 5 hours |
39 |
11 |
The
result shows that 49 % of
respondents are male and 51 %
are female. 11% of respondents are less than 15 years, 17 % of respondents are
between age of 15-20 years and 72 % of respondents are between age of 20-25
years. 17 % of the
respondents are higher school students, 17% of
respondents are diploma holders, 27%
of respondents are degree holders, and 45% respondents are post graduate. 54 %
of respondents belong to urban area, 46 % of respondents belong to rural area. In case of social media usage, all 350 respondents use social media.
Out of this, 46% of respondents are using social media from 2 years or more, 12% of respondents are using social media from 6 months to 1
year. On the other side, social
media usage in 45 % respondents is less than an hour in a
day, in 5% of respondents is 1 to 2 hours per day, in 39 % of
respondents is 2 to 5 hours on daily basis, and in 11 % of respondents is more than 5 hours.
Hypotheses
Testing:
Data collected from the investigation is analysed in smartPLS. Cronbach alpha for
all variables is greater than 0.69. Multiple regression analysis as research
sampling tool was
used to test
proposed hypotheses. The investigation focused on
six variables: Content, E-Word of Mouth, advertisements, Rating and Reviews, Social Media
Influencers and Entertainment, and validate their affect on buying decision process of digital
natives
Table 2: Influence of social
media dimensions on buying decision process of
digital natives
Dependent |
Independent |
Beta |
T |
Sig. |
R2 |
F |
Sig. |
|
Social Media Influencers |
-0.089 |
-1.056 |
0.292 |
|
|
|
Need Recognition |
Entertainment |
0.056 |
0.548 |
0.582 |
0.343 |
25.67 |
.000a |
|
Advertisements |
0.192 |
2.034 |
0.042 |
|
|
|
|
Rating and Reviews |
-0.152 |
-1.467 |
0.142 |
|
|
|
|
Content |
0.286 |
3.005 |
0.002 |
|
|
|
|
E-Word of Mouth |
0.395 |
7.467 |
0 |
|
|
|
Information search |
Social Media Influencers |
-0.012 |
-0.153 |
0.877 |
0.58 |
64.39 |
.000a |
Entertainment |
0.033 |
0.401 |
0.687 |
||||
Advertisements |
-0.015 |
-0.206 |
0.835 |
||||
Rating and Reviews |
0.032 |
0.387 |
0.697 |
||||
Content |
0.581 |
7.513 |
0 |
||||
E-Word of Mouth |
0.252 |
5.879 |
0 |
||||
Evaluation of alternatives |
Social Media Influencers |
-0.037 |
-0.486 |
0.629 |
0.52 |
52.12 |
.000a |
Entertainment |
0.088 |
0.974 |
0.331 |
||||
Advertisements |
0.069 |
0.847 |
0.399 |
||||
Rating and Reviews |
0.185 |
2.051 |
0.04 |
||||
Content |
0.312 |
3.804 |
0 |
||||
E-Word of Mouth |
0.243 |
5.34 |
0 |
||||
Purchase Decision |
Social Media Influencers |
-0.071 |
-0.987 |
0.326 |
0.54 |
58 |
.000a |
Entertainment |
0.269 |
3.108 |
0.003 |
||||
Advertisements |
0.014 |
0.164 |
0.868 |
||||
Rating and Reviews |
-0.014 |
-0.152 |
0.87 |
||||
Content |
0.445 |
5.603 |
0 |
||||
E-Word of Mouth |
0.242 |
5.281 |
0 |
||||
Post purchase behaviour |
Social Media Influencers |
-0.07 |
-0.869 |
0.39 |
0.4 |
34 |
.000a |
Entertainment |
0.114 |
1.166 |
0.245 |
||||
Advertisements |
0.08 |
0.794 |
0.429 |
||||
Rating and Reviews |
0.14 |
1.324 |
0.188 |
||||
Content |
0.324 |
3.575 |
0 |
||||
E-Word of Mouth |
0.19 |
3.769 |
0 |
As shown in the table (3) of multiple regression analysis, R-squared for need recognition stage
is equal to 0.343, which means that 34.3% of the variance in
need recognition as dependent variable is due to social media as independent
variable. R-square for information search stage is 0.58, which designates that 58% of the variance in
information search as dependent variable is due to social media as independent
variable. R-squared for evaluation of alternatives stage is 0.52, which denotes
that 52% of the
variance in evaluation of alternatives as dependent variable is due to social
media as independent variable. R-squared for Purchase decision stage is 0.54,
which signifies that 54% of variance in purchase decision as dependent variable
is due to social media as independent variable. R-squared for post purchase behaviour
stage is 0.40, which indicates that 40% of the
variance in post purchase behaviour
as dependent variable is due to social media as independent variable. For all
models, P-value is 0.000 and it is <0.05, thus the model is significant
statistically. Table 2 elaborates that the independent variable (social media)
has significant relationship F= (25.67, 64.39, 52.12, 58, 34) with P<.05
with dependent variables; five stages of buying decision process. According to result
analysis in Table (2), content, E-word of mouth, and advertisements have substantial impact on need recognition. Entertainment, content, and E-word of mouth substantially impact information search stage. Rating and Reviews, content, and E-word of mouth have strong impact on evaluation of
alternatives stage. Entertainment, content, and E-word of mouth purchase have significant impact on
purchase decision stage. Rating
and Reviews, content, and E-word
of mouth substantially
impact post
purchase stage. Now,
it is evident that factors
of social media (Content and E-Word of Mouth) have significant impact on all stages of
consumer buying process. This means that these factors are considered as decisive factors that have influence on buying decision process.
Dependent Variable |
R2 |
F |
Sig. |
Order |
Need Recognition |
0.343 |
92.196 |
0 |
5 |
Information Search |
0.58 |
273.254 |
0 |
1 |
Evaluation of alternatives |
0.52 |
265.59 |
0 |
3 |
Purchase Decision |
0.54 |
293.6 |
0 |
2 |
Post purchase |
0.4 |
182.03 |
0 |
4 |
From table (3),the results make it clear that all assumed study hypotheses are rejected, and making
it is apparent that social media as an
independent variable impact all stages of buying decision process significantly.
This investigation
demonstrated that social media
affects Information
Search stage, purchase decision, and evaluation stage in
majority.
Consumers use social media mostly for obtaining the information
about products and services of different brands, followed by making mind to
actually buy product. This stage converts consumer purchase intention into
purchase decision. Need recognition stage is least affected by social media in
influencing consumer behaviour. Out of all social media factors, content and E-word of mouth strongly alter purchase decisions
of consumers. Content on social media is preferred by majority of respondents,
followed by E-world of Mouth. Results have made it very apparent that consumers
in Chandigarh are very active on social media with Facebook being the most
accessed platform. All in all, it is needless to say that social media has
become an imperative element for consumers that help them in deciding what to
buy, from where to buy.
Research Implications
The results offer imperative implications for
practitioners and researchers. For researcher, a new research model has been developed
to bridge factors of social media and consumers buying decision process. Social
media stands out to be an independent conduit for market communications where
consumers have direct link with different brands. People are using wide range
of social media platforms like, Instagram, Facebook and is not limited by the
nation’s boundaries. Social media has become a new digital market for
researchers to study behaviour of domestic as well as international consumers.
It gives real insight of various attributes of consumer behaviour like, if one
post is being shared by millions of people, it means they are agreed with
statement or photo or video. Researchers can further investigate reasons for
liking that particular post. So, social media provides ample scope for
researchers to explore new dimensions of consumer behaviour especially current
generation of digital natives as they are the one who are most exposed to digital
world. The study provides scope for
business houses to deal with changing consumer behaviour. With the invention of
technology, especially social media, consumers got a voice to speak about their
likings and preferences towards various brands.
Users on Social media build relationships with each other’s and
companies on various popular social networks. Social interaction ties depict
the width of the social network by focusing on user’s relationships on social
network. Consumers form a network on social media and develop interaction ties
which leads to increase in frequency of communication among members, thus it has
a multiplying influence on the final outcomes. Social interaction ties act as encouraging
channel where members freely share their buying experiences including product
reviews. This change in consumer behaviour because of social media made social
media a prospective field for organisations to discover opportunities to widen
their customer base.
Ruiz-Gomez, A., (2019). Digital Fame and Fortune in the
age of Social Media: A Classification of
social media influencers,
aDResearch ESIC. Nº 19 Vol 19 Primer semestre, enero-junio 2019 · Páges.
8 a 29, https://doi.org/10.7263/adresic-019-01.